Best Eyeliners: Pencil, Gel, Liquid, Felt Tip

Hannah sent me an email asking about the best eyeliners almost a year ago! After lots of testing and research, I've got some of the best eyeliners that last. I tried to be as versatile as possible, giving options of every price, need and type! I left out cake liners, since they aren't as common right now, but let me know if you need suggestions. Everything is linked below.

Best Pencil Eyeliners:

• Laura Gellar I-CARE WATERPROOF EYELINER--Great for sensitive eyes, comes in 19 colors, and nice on the waterline--sharpener in the cap
• Maybelline Unstoppable Mechanical Eyeliner--Great for small eyes
• Tarte Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner--My newest fave since it features a pencil on one end and liquid liner on the other. Dries matte!
• Urban Decay 24/7--A classic that comes in MANY colors and lasts for hours
• Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay in Place Liner--I love the smudger on the end. 

Best Gel Liners

• Loreal Infallible Laquer Liner--Very easy to use
• Stila Smudge Pots--Can be used as shadow or primer (there are plenty of colors other than black) or as a liner
• Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Liner--Comes in a few shades and is an award-winner
• YSL Long Wear Cream Liner--This stuff lasts on the oiliest of skin
• Tarte Clay Pot Waterproof Liner--Comes in matte finish or shimmer finish

Tip: Store pots upside down to help prevent drying out.

Best Felt Tip Marker Liners

• Sephora Fine Line--Picked this up on a whim and was pleasantly surprised. Very easy to use to get a cat eye
• Eyeko Black Magic Liquid Liner--Inspired by calligraphy in Japan, this liner lasts for years before replacing
• Jessie's Girl Liquid Liner--Found at Rite Aid (and online, I linked it and all liners) this is my pretty close version of the Eyeko liner, but at a cheaper price
• Stila Stay All Day--This comes in several colors and is usually at THE top of the list as being the best. It is my 2nd fave.
• Urban Decay Perversion--Love the fine tip on this!
• Kat Von D Tattoo--My fave!

Tip: Shake before using

Best Liquid Liners:

• Lancome Artliner--Liquid liners can be tricky or intimidating, but this one is easy to use!
• Maybelline Ultra Liner--A classic, waterproof formula that never lets me down
• Paula Dorf Transfomer--This is my makeup artist secret. Take any shadow and turn it into a long-lasting liquid liner with this! Sure, you can do that with nearly any clear liquid, but this is smudge-proof. Works well on brides too, especially with false lashes.
• Lip Ink Liquid Liner--Polyvore wouldn't clip the image when I was making the collage, so no pic here--click the link to see. This is made in USA with natural, vegan, organic, & kosher botanical ingredients. 100% smear-proof, money guaranteed!

Of course, it is impossible to please everyone, 

which is why I welcome your favorites in the comments!

Extra Elle:

I usually do my eyebrows myself, but I prefer them threaded. I finally found a place I like in Atlanta!

Thanks for your comments yesterday on my post!